Why We Chose Not to Use Bentonite Clay or Alcohol in Our Products

In the world of personal care and oral hygiene, ingredient transparency has become a cornerstone of consumer trust. At Sheer Alternatives, we embrace this philosophy wholeheartedly, ensuring our products, such as The Texas Toothpaste, are crafted with the utmost care and consideration. In our quest for excellence, we have consciously chosen not to incorporate certain popular ingredients like bentonite clay and alcohol. This decision aligns with our commitment to using minimal, yet effective ingredients that prioritize safety and efficacy.

The Bentonite Clay Debate

Bentonite clay has gained popularity in various personal care products due to its natural origin and purported benefits. However, there are compelling reasons why we decided against its inclusion in our formulations.

1. Potential for Heavy Metal Contamination

One of the primary concerns surrounding bentonite clay is the risk of heavy metal contamination. Bentonite clay is often mined from the earth, where it can absorb elements like lead, arsenic, and mercury. According to a study published in the Journal of Environmental Science and Health (2016), the concentration of heavy metals in bentonite clay can vary significantly depending on its source (1). This variability poses a potential health risk, particularly for products intended for oral use, like toothpaste.

2. Inconsistent Quality Control

The quality of bentonite clay can vary depending on its geographical source and processing. This inconsistency makes it difficult to guarantee the same level of efficacy and safety across different batches. As a company committed to maintaining high standards, we believe in using ingredients with dependable quality control measures. A report from the International Journal of Cosmetic Science (2019) highlights that the lack of standardization in clay processing can lead to unpredictable product performance (2).

3. Impact on Tooth Enamel

While bentonite clay is often advertised as being beneficial for teeth due to its abrasive nature, this very characteristic can pose a risk. Excessive abrasiveness can erode tooth enamel over time, weakening teeth and making them more susceptible to cavities. A study conducted by the American Dental Association (2018) cautions against the use of highly abrasive substances in oral care products, emphasizing the importance of protecting enamel (3). At Sheer Alternatives, we prioritize the long-term health of our customers' teeth, avoiding ingredients that may compromise enamel integrity.

The Case Against Alcohol

Alcohol is another ingredient commonly found in personal care products, particularly mouthwashes, due to its antibacterial properties. However, there are several reasons why we have opted not to include alcohol in The Texas Toothpaste.

1. Drying Effects on Oral Mucosa

Alcohol is known for its drying properties, which can be detrimental to the delicate tissues of the oral cavity. The drying effect can disrupt the natural balance of saliva, leading to dry mouth, or xerostomia, which is not only uncomfortable but can also contribute to bad breath and an increased risk of cavities. A study published in the Journal of Clinical Dentistry (2020) found that alcohol-based mouthwashes can exacerbate dry mouth symptoms in susceptible individuals (4). By excluding alcohol from our products, we aim to promote a healthier oral environment.

2. Potential for Irritation

For individuals with sensitive oral tissues or pre-existing conditions, alcohol can be an irritant, causing discomfort and even inflammation. The British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery (2017) reported instances of oral mucosal irritation linked to alcohol-containing oral care products (5). Our commitment to gentle, non-irritating formulations steered us toward safer alternatives that prioritize comfort and efficacy without compromising on quality.

3. Unwanted Interactions with Other Ingredients

The presence of alcohol can sometimes lead to undesirable interactions with other ingredients in a product, potentially affecting its overall stability and effectiveness. By omitting alcohol from our formulations, we ensure that our carefully selected ingredients work harmoniously to deliver optimal results.

The Sheer Alternatives Approach: Minimal Ingredients, Maximum Efficacy

At Sheer Alternatives, our guiding principle is to use minimal ingredients while maximizing efficacy. This philosophy is at the heart of The Texas Toothpaste, where each ingredient is chosen with intention and care.

1. Natural, High-Quality Ingredients

Instead of relying on bentonite clay, we opt for a gentle, ADA approved natural abrasive sodium bicarbonate, commonly know as baking soda. Baking soda has a dental RDA( clean teeth without compromising enamel safety. Our toothpaste is enriched with xylitol, a natural sweetener known for its ability to reduce cavity-causing bacteria while adding a pleasant taste.

2. Emphasis on Safety and Transparency

Transparency is key to building trust with our customers. We provide clear, concise information about each ingredient in our products, ensuring that consumers are well-informed about what they are using. This commitment to transparency extends to our decision not to use potential irritants like alcohol.

3. A Holistic Approach to Oral Health

We believe in a holistic approach to oral health, where the ingredients we choose work synergistically to support overall well-being. Our toothpaste is designed to enhance the oral microbiome, promote healthy gums, and protect tooth enamel, all without the need for potentially harmful or controversial components.

Conclusion

Choosing the right ingredients for personal care products is a responsibility we take seriously at Sheer Alternatives. Our decision to exclude bentonite clay and alcohol from The Texas Toothpaste is rooted in a commitment to safety, efficacy, and transparency. By opting for gentle, natural ingredients and prioritizing minimalism in our formulations, we provide our customers with products they can trust. Our dedication to quality and integrity ensures that The Texas Toothpaste is not just a product, but a promise of healthier smiles and a brighter future.

References